Yes. Apparat has 148 songs listed in a dataset used to train AI music models.

Used for training 148

songs in LAION-DISCO-12M under the artist name

A list of 12 million songs on YouTube Music, gathered by walking artist pages, that LAION published in 2024 for training general music models.

Including BRANDENBURG, Komponent (Telefon Tel Aviv RMX), Candil De La Calle

Listed under the artist name 148 songs in LAION-DISCO-12M

Matched exactly: this YouTube Music artist id is the one the dataset lists these songs under.

BRANDENBURG

Listed as Apparat – BRANDENBURG (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 0B1l2CbQ82E · row 0B1l2CbQ82E

LAION-DISCO-12M

Komponent (Telefon Tel Aviv RMX)

Listed as Apparat – Komponent (Telefon Tel Aviv RMX) (Silizium) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 2a3h_SiitCw · row 2a3h_SiitCw

LAION-DISCO-12M

Candil De La Calle

Listed as Apparat – Candil De La Calle (Candil De La Calle) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 3B7aNAXFKBg · row 3B7aNAXFKBg

LAION-DISCO-12M

Arcadia (Telefon Tel Aviv Rmx)

Listed as Apparat – Arcadia (Telefon Tel Aviv Rmx) (Arcadia Remixes) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 6FSBNR5AxLY · row 6FSBNR5AxLY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Black Water

Listed as Apparat – Black Water (Black Water) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 7T5jaGerm8o · row 7T5jaGerm8o

LAION-DISCO-12M

Joel

Listed as Apparat – Joel (Soundtracks: Dämonen) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 85ZNdK6C7dg · row 85ZNdK6C7dg

LAION-DISCO-12M

Turbo Dreams

Listed as Ellen Allien, Apparat – Turbo Dreams (Orchestra of Bubbles) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 9zoMfnY73Bo · row 9zoMfnY73Bo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Komponent

Listed as Apparat – Komponent (Silizium) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video BD5Mqy-lyNw · row BD5Mqy-lyNw

LAION-DISCO-12M

OUTLIER (Solomun Remix)

Listed as Apparat – OUTLIER (Solomun Remix) (OUTLIER (Solomun Remix)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video BElOoUK-aIs · row BElOoUK-aIs

LAION-DISCO-12M

Silizium

Listed as Apparat – Silizium (Silizium) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video C2Q4chVAtrw · row C2Q4chVAtrw

LAION-DISCO-12M

Habakuk

Listed as Apparat – Habakuk (Soundtracks: Dämonen) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Eu3-P8_Xg8g · row Eu3-P8_Xg8g

LAION-DISCO-12M

Escape

Listed as Apparat – Escape (The Devil's Walk) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video IFayqxmZjeE · row IFayqxmZjeE

LAION-DISCO-12M

DAWAN

Listed as Apparat – DAWAN (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video IcSVBeIOIl8 · row IcSVBeIOIl8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Do Not Break

Listed as Ellen Allien, Apparat – Do Not Break (Orchestra of Bubbles) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video JZ4eyij_Rko · row JZ4eyij_Rko

LAION-DISCO-12M

Not A Number

Listed as Apparat – Not A Number (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video OFz0JtypI5U · row OFz0JtypI5U

LAION-DISCO-12M

Sweet Unrest

Listed as Apparat – Sweet Unrest (The Devil's Walk) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Rh3hSYgZyJE · row Rh3hSYgZyJE

LAION-DISCO-12M

HEROIST

Listed as Apparat – HEROIST (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Ttxv3RsPnz0 · row Ttxv3RsPnz0

LAION-DISCO-12M

OUTLIER

Listed as Apparat – OUTLIER (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video U9AREOy0T8I · row U9AREOy0T8I

LAION-DISCO-12M

Leave Me Alone

Listed as Ellen Allien, Apparat – Leave Me Alone (Orchestra of Bubbles) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video VS_X4HMfPNo · row VS_X4HMfPNo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Useless Information

Listed as Apparat – Useless Information (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Whxrunpg9h0 · row Whxrunpg9h0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Arcadia

Listed as Apparat – Arcadia (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video ZW2xreeR6yI · row ZW2xreeR6yI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Goodbye (with Soap & Skin) (feat. Soap & Skin)

Listed as Apparat – Goodbye (with Soap & Skin) (feat. Soap & Skin) (The Devil's Walk) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video _7ctaqEFJoA · row _7ctaqEFJoA

LAION-DISCO-12M

Ash / Black Veil

Listed as Apparat – Ash / Black Veil (Ash / Black Veil) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video _TGexa-uQKk · row _TGexa-uQKk

LAION-DISCO-12M

IN GRAVITAS

Listed as Apparat – IN GRAVITAS (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video az_kSbff2t4 · row az_kSbff2t4

LAION-DISCO-12M

Headup

Listed as Apparat – Headup (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video bWqYJ_-EbLk · row bWqYJ_-EbLk

LAION-DISCO-12M

Rotary

Listed as Ellen Allien, Apparat – Rotary (Orchestra of Bubbles) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video b_a8JfjUsow · row b_a8JfjUsow

LAION-DISCO-12M

Holdon

Listed as Apparat – Holdon (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video cK6kSfKc-eE · row cK6kSfKc-eE

LAION-DISCO-12M

VOI_DO

Listed as Apparat – VOI_DO (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video dcXa0LxA9iE · row dcXa0LxA9iE

LAION-DISCO-12M

PV

Listed as Apparat – PV (Krieg und Frieden (Music for Theatre)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video dqU7h2Lbyec · row dqU7h2Lbyec

LAION-DISCO-12M

Bad Kingdom (Lulu's Version)

Listed as Apparat – Bad Kingdom (Lulu's Version) (Soundtracks: Stay Still) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video dziSKtiZdgM · row dziSKtiZdgM

LAION-DISCO-12M

You Don’t Know Me

Listed as Apparat – You Don’t Know Me (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video eKVy8_01GdI · row eKVy8_01GdI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Fractales Pt. 1

Listed as Apparat – Fractales Pt. 1 (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video eSaFyVzjj7w · row eSaFyVzjj7w

LAION-DISCO-12M

Birds

Listed as Apparat – Birds (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video fUCZ5f2UVR8 · row fUCZ5f2UVR8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Your House Is My World

Listed as Apparat – Your House Is My World (The Devil's Walk) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video gPmQ8fNozn4 · row gPmQ8fNozn4

LAION-DISCO-12M

Sayulita (DJ-KiCKS)

Listed as Apparat – Sayulita (DJ-KiCKS) (Sayulita EP) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video hRQxzR5uPr4 · row hRQxzR5uPr4

LAION-DISCO-12M

K&F Thema

Listed as Apparat – K&F Thema (Krieg und Frieden (Music for Theatre)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video iuCz4FQaUcI · row iuCz4FQaUcI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Limelight

Listed as Apparat – Limelight (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video m_0kwBrVOQY · row m_0kwBrVOQY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Way Out

Listed as Ellen Allien, Apparat – Way Out (Orchestra of Bubbles) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video nHp6NXaGMxo · row nHp6NXaGMxo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Song of Los

Listed as Apparat – Song of Los (The Devil's Walk) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video q78HpalbBgc · row q78HpalbBgc

LAION-DISCO-12M

Hailin From The Edge

Listed as Apparat – Hailin From The Edge (Walls) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video qw_YPOILluo · row qw_YPOILluo

LAION-DISCO-12M

The Past

Listed as Apparat – The Past (Soundtracks: Equals Sessions) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video qy8Vgw-CdYk · row qy8Vgw-CdYk

LAION-DISCO-12M

LAMINAR FLOW

Listed as Apparat – LAMINAR FLOW (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video sDEAyzZ9WhM · row sDEAyzZ9WhM

LAION-DISCO-12M

Jet

Listed as Ellen Allien, Apparat – Jet (Orchestra of Bubbles) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video t1Lspz6WHzo · row t1Lspz6WHzo

LAION-DISCO-12M

A Bang In The Void

Listed as Apparat – A Bang In The Void (The Devil's Walk) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video tyaY7JJHeWg · row tyaY7JJHeWg

LAION-DISCO-12M

HEROIST (Substance Remix)

Listed as Apparat – HEROIST (Substance Remix) (HEROIST (Substance Remixes)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video wYBJffuMxMA · row wYBJffuMxMA

LAION-DISCO-12M

EQ_BREAK

Listed as Apparat – EQ_BREAK (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video wrs1uqM_YwE · row wrs1uqM_YwE

LAION-DISCO-12M

CARONTE

Listed as Apparat – CARONTE (LP5) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video xRVLN418d1Q · row xRVLN418d1Q

LAION-DISCO-12M

The Soft Voices Die

Listed as Apparat – The Soft Voices Die (The Devil's Walk) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video xswdNjhFy1w · row xswdNjhFy1w

LAION-DISCO-12M

K&F Thema (pizzicato)

Listed as Apparat – K&F Thema (pizzicato) (Krieg und Frieden (Music for Theatre)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video yCBzq2XHJ9U · row yCBzq2XHJ9U

LAION-DISCO-12M

A Violent Sky

Listed as Apparat – A Violent Sky (Krieg und Frieden (Music for Theatre)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video zhsRgkDl-0Q · row zhsRgkDl-0Q

LAION-DISCO-12M

What this means

Last reviewed 2026-09-24.

Presence in a public research dataset shows that a clip of your recording was listed by academic or industry researchers as material for building or testing audio models. It does not by itself show which commercial products, if any, used the clip. The legal picture is moving. On 31 July 2026 the Regional Court of Munich I ruled in GEMA's case against Suno (case 42 O 763/25) that reproducing works for training, holding them in a model in retrievable form, and generating similar outputs can each infringe copyright under German and EU law; the judgment is not final and can be appealed. In the United States, Warner Music Group settled its claims against Suno on 25 November 2025 with a licensing deal, while the parallel claims by Universal and Sony were still pending at that point. Since then BMG (12 August 2026) and Believe/TuneCore (8 September 2026) have signed opt-in licensing deals with Suno.

What you can do

3 routes. None is a guarantee.

UK, PRS members. Send PRS for Music your report and ask what collective or licensing route covers your works.
- PRS for Music and Artificial Intelligence, Version 1 (October 2025), 2025-10-01
- PRS for Music: AI and music copyright, 2026-09-24
Germany, GEMA members. GEMA won a first-instance ruling against Suno on 31 July 2026 and has a licensing model. Ask how they apply to your repertoire.
- GEMA: Suno AI and OpenAI, GEMA sues for fair compensation, 2025-01-21
- DLA Piper: GEMA v Suno, Munich Regional Court judgment of 31 July 2026, 2026-08-28
- Music Business Worldwide: Germany's GEMA launches AI Charter, 2024-11-05
Signed to Warner, BMG or Believe/TuneCore. Each has an opt-in licensing deal with Suno. Ask your label what opting in or out means for you and whether any settlement money reaches artists.
- Music Business Worldwide: Warner Music Group settles with Suno, 2025-11-25
- Music Ally: Suno signs another music licensing deal, with BMG, 2026-08-12
- Music Business Worldwide: Suno inks global deal with Believe, 2026-09-08

Is this you?

Check another name

These pages report where identifiers from public research datasets point. Presence in a dataset is a fact about the dataset, not a claim about the channel or artist, and says nothing about what any company did with the material. If you are this artist and want this page removed, see removals.