Yes. Circle of Dust has 153 songs listed in a dataset used to train AI music models.

Used for training 153

songs in LAION-DISCO-12M under the artist name

A list of 12 million songs on YouTube Music, gathered by walking artist pages, that LAION published in 2024 for training general music models.

Including Hive Mind (Animattronic Volcania Remix), Consequence (25th Anniversary Mix), Nothing Sacred (Kaixo Remix)

Listed under the artist name 153 songs in LAION-DISCO-12M

Matched exactly: this YouTube Music artist id is the one the dataset lists these songs under.

Hive Mind (Animattronic Volcania Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Hive Mind (Animattronic Volcania Remix) (Hive Mind (Animattronic Volcania Remix)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 0QLsIswDZAQ · row 0QLsIswDZAQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Consequence (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Consequence (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 0nAkQre--_U · row 0nAkQre--_U

LAION-DISCO-12M

Nothing Sacred (Kaixo Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Nothing Sacred (Kaixo Remix) (Circle of Dust (Remixed)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 1HJ_UQASKZI · row 1HJ_UQASKZI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Twisted Reality (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Twisted Reality (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 2MucDIBhQVc · row 2MucDIBhQVc

LAION-DISCO-12M

Aggressor (Regressive Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Aggressor (Regressive Mix) (Brainchild (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 58WY8cbKEiI · row 58WY8cbKEiI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Self Inflict (The Anix Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Self Inflict (The Anix Remix) (Circle of Dust (Remixed)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 6m-EJhL_PwY · row 6m-EJhL_PwY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Course of Ruin

Listed as Circle of Dust – Course of Ruin (Brainchild (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 7HzNYsUI2IQ · row 7HzNYsUI2IQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Perelandra

Listed as Circle of Dust – Perelandra (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 7gSOag5cRLE · row 7gSOag5cRLE

LAION-DISCO-12M

Bed of Nails (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Bed of Nails (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Ak7u30gCZog · row Ak7u30gCZog

LAION-DISCO-12M

Dust to Dust (Zardonic Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Dust to Dust (Zardonic Remix) (alt_Machines (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video AmGHtY4ZX-0 · row AmGHtY4ZX-0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Twisted Reality

Listed as Circle of Dust – Twisted Reality (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video CZ6ocbRAwZs · row CZ6ocbRAwZs

LAION-DISCO-12M

Nightfall (FreqGen Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Nightfall (FreqGen Remix) (Circle of Dust (Remixed)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video CsxXnfeJDJ8 · row CsxXnfeJDJ8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Deviate (Void Chapter Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Deviate (Void Chapter Remix) (Deviate (Void Chapter Remix)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video E-q0GweyNdY · row E-q0GweyNdY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Consequence (Alex Yarmak Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Consequence (Alex Yarmak Remix) (Circle of Dust (Remixed)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video ER-dplV-ARE · row ER-dplV-ARE

LAION-DISCO-12M

Babylon

Listed as Circle of Dust – Babylon (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video EiehBBUxX5M · row EiehBBUxX5M

LAION-DISCO-12M

Self Inflict

Listed as Circle of Dust – Self Inflict (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video GAcpR4uW5Ts · row GAcpR4uW5Ts

LAION-DISCO-12M

Your Noise (1997)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Your Noise (1997) (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video GYRcj_ZjBds · row GYRcj_ZjBds

LAION-DISCO-12M

Parasite

Listed as Circle of Dust – Parasite (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video GxgCsIlnpVM · row GxgCsIlnpVM

LAION-DISCO-12M

Neophyte (Zeromancer Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Neophyte (Zeromancer Remix) (alt_Machines (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video IlYbIoLdqzo · row IlYbIoLdqzo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Drum Machines of Our Disgrace

Listed as Circle of Dust – Drum Machines of Our Disgrace (alt_Machines (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video JoeT-xiTvZI · row JoeT-xiTvZI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Enshrined

Listed as Circle of Dust – Enshrined (Brainchild (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video KsZUMg-lTSs · row KsZUMg-lTSs

LAION-DISCO-12M

Nothing Sacred (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Nothing Sacred (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Nb8GKzRLqeQ · row Nb8GKzRLqeQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Nightfall (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Nightfall (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video PD_lbXUjEmQ · row PD_lbXUjEmQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Rational Lies

Listed as Circle of Dust – Rational Lies (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video PX2jauWrw8M · row PX2jauWrw8M

LAION-DISCO-12M

Dissolved

Listed as Circle of Dust – Dissolved (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video QquSrzmErO8 · row QquSrzmErO8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Twisted Reality (Void Chapter Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Twisted Reality (Void Chapter Remix) (Circle of Dust (Remixed)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video SSLJwYXV-p0 · row SSLJwYXV-p0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Thulcandra

Listed as Circle of Dust – Thulcandra (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video SzT6f__8UWQ · row SzT6f__8UWQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Nightfall

Listed as Circle of Dust – Nightfall (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video X5tSnIHionk · row X5tSnIHionk

LAION-DISCO-12M

Demoralize

Listed as Circle of Dust – Demoralize (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Y-RqKCEJuuY · row Y-RqKCEJuuY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Neurachem (Kaixo Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Neurachem (Kaixo Remix) (Neurachem (Kaixo Remix)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Y4nNfNc2vWY · row Y4nNfNc2vWY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Heldweller

Listed as Circle of Dust – Heldweller (Metamorphosis (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video _0fta40dXwM · row _0fta40dXwM

LAION-DISCO-12M

Parasite (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Parasite (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video bezgG8MTNds · row bezgG8MTNds

LAION-DISCO-12M

Pale Reflection

Listed as Circle of Dust – Pale Reflection (Brainchild (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video co5di3HMiG0 · row co5di3HMiG0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Mesmerized

Listed as Circle of Dust – Mesmerized (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video dPjOk4Ot4Ns · row dPjOk4Ot4Ns

LAION-DISCO-12M

Blindeye

Listed as Circle of Dust – Blindeye (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video dT_yFMBVBzQ · row dT_yFMBVBzQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

alt_Human (3FORCE Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – alt_Human (3FORCE Remix) (alt_Machines (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video gpSS-rlmZfE · row gpSS-rlmZfE

LAION-DISCO-12M

Signal

Listed as Circle of Dust – Signal (Machines of Our Disgrace) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video iZujETgXxnY · row iZujETgXxnY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Self Inflict (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Self Inflict (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video ikchsCNncM0 · row ikchsCNncM0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Descend (Sebastian Komor Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Descend (Sebastian Komor Remix) (Descend (Sebastian Komor Remix)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video iyZIddvpkVo · row iyZIddvpkVo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Dissolved (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Dissolved (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video oIQYys9NXTY · row oIQYys9NXTY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Bed of Nails

Listed as Circle of Dust – Bed of Nails (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video r7a1V_y6hk0 · row r7a1V_y6hk0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Demoralize (25th Anniversary Mix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Demoralize (25th Anniversary Mix) (Circle of Dust (25th Anniversary Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video rjUPT9P251A · row rjUPT9P251A

LAION-DISCO-12M

Telltale Crime (The Forgotten Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Telltale Crime (The Forgotten Remix) (Telltale Crime (The Forgotten Remix)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video tWv5Yd9ELW4 · row tWv5Yd9ELW4

LAION-DISCO-12M

Hive Mind (The Anix Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Hive Mind (The Anix Remix) (Hive Mind (The Anix Remix)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video tsPPGaIYxn8 · row tsPPGaIYxn8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Nihilistic Void

Listed as Circle of Dust – Nihilistic Void (Metamorphosis (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video uoSUw_3l510 · row uoSUw_3l510

LAION-DISCO-12M

Chasm (Version 2.1.0)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Chasm (Version 2.1.0) (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video w2Xu0XvEO3M · row w2Xu0XvEO3M

LAION-DISCO-12M

Rational Lies (Cyanotic Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Rational Lies (Cyanotic Remix) (Circle of Dust (Remixed)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video yI3icU9WlV8 · row yI3icU9WlV8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Hate Opened Wide

Listed as Circle of Dust – Hate Opened Wide (Disengage (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video yfkaNfeG4FQ · row yfkaNfeG4FQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Heldweller (Drumcorps Remix)

Listed as Circle of Dust – Heldweller (Drumcorps Remix) (Brainchild (Remixed)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video z2gPRmr-7mI · row z2gPRmr-7mI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Consequence

Listed as Circle of Dust – Consequence (Circle of Dust (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video zPFFsNI3O_o · row zPFFsNI3O_o

LAION-DISCO-12M

What this means

Last reviewed 2026-09-24.

Presence in a public research dataset shows that a clip of your recording was listed by academic or industry researchers as material for building or testing audio models. It does not by itself show which commercial products, if any, used the clip. The legal picture is moving. On 31 July 2026 the Regional Court of Munich I ruled in GEMA's case against Suno (case 42 O 763/25) that reproducing works for training, holding them in a model in retrievable form, and generating similar outputs can each infringe copyright under German and EU law; the judgment is not final and can be appealed. In the United States, Warner Music Group settled its claims against Suno on 25 November 2025 with a licensing deal, while the parallel claims by Universal and Sony were still pending at that point. Since then BMG (12 August 2026) and Believe/TuneCore (8 September 2026) have signed opt-in licensing deals with Suno.

What you can do

3 routes. None is a guarantee.

UK, PRS members. Send PRS for Music your report and ask what collective or licensing route covers your works.
- PRS for Music and Artificial Intelligence, Version 1 (October 2025), 2025-10-01
- PRS for Music: AI and music copyright, 2026-09-24
Germany, GEMA members. GEMA won a first-instance ruling against Suno on 31 July 2026 and has a licensing model. Ask how they apply to your repertoire.
- GEMA: Suno AI and OpenAI, GEMA sues for fair compensation, 2025-01-21
- DLA Piper: GEMA v Suno, Munich Regional Court judgment of 31 July 2026, 2026-08-28
- Music Business Worldwide: Germany's GEMA launches AI Charter, 2024-11-05
Signed to Warner, BMG or Believe/TuneCore. Each has an opt-in licensing deal with Suno. Ask your label what opting in or out means for you and whether any settlement money reaches artists.
- Music Business Worldwide: Warner Music Group settles with Suno, 2025-11-25
- Music Ally: Suno signs another music licensing deal, with BMG, 2026-08-12
- Music Business Worldwide: Suno inks global deal with Believe, 2026-09-08

Is this you?

Check another name

These pages report where identifiers from public research datasets point. Presence in a dataset is a fact about the dataset, not a claim about the channel or artist, and says nothing about what any company did with the material. If you are this artist and want this page removed, see removals.