Yes. Howard Goodman has 63 songs listed in a dataset used to train AI music models.

Used for training 63

songs in LAION-DISCO-12M under the artist name

A list of 12 million songs on YouTube Music, gathered by walking artist pages, that LAION published in 2024 for training general music models.

Including When God’s Chariot Comes, Tellin' My Blues Goodbye, Didn't It Rain

Listed under the artist name 63 songs in LAION-DISCO-12M

Matched exactly: this YouTube Music artist id is the one the dataset lists these songs under.

When God’s Chariot Comes

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Larry Gatlin, J.D. Sumner – When God’s Chariot Comes (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video -PyY6F7jQqk · row -PyY6F7jQqk

LAION-DISCO-12M

Tellin' My Blues Goodbye

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – Tellin' My Blues Goodbye (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 19_JYSMj7TE · row 19_JYSMj7TE

LAION-DISCO-12M

Didn't It Rain

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Hope's Call – Didn't It Rain (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 1cJN1AIRe8U · row 1cJN1AIRe8U

LAION-DISCO-12M

Big Homecoming

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Jake Hess – Big Homecoming (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 2vdrGukGGKs · row 2vdrGukGGKs

LAION-DISCO-12M

We'll Understand It Better By And By (Live)

Listed as Gaither, Howard Goodman, Lillie Knauls, Jake Hess – We'll Understand It Better By And By (Live) (Landmark (Live)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 37IvYUe4U_Y · row 37IvYUe4U_Y

LAION-DISCO-12M

I Wouldn't Take Nothin for My Journey Now (Homecoming Friends Version)

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Greater Vision, Jason Crabb – I Wouldn't Take Nothin for My Journey Now (Homecoming Friends Version) (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 3gZV2tgE56M · row 3gZV2tgE56M

LAION-DISCO-12M

I Don't Regret A Mile (Live)

Listed as Gaither, Johnny Minick, Guy Penrod, Howard Goodman – I Don't Regret A Mile (Live) (Nashville Homecoming) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 4D8vCzNHRLA · row 4D8vCzNHRLA

LAION-DISCO-12M

When They Ring the Bells of Heaven

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – When They Ring the Bells of Heaven (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 6EgdtwfFZMs · row 6EgdtwfFZMs

LAION-DISCO-12M

It Is No Secret

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – It Is No Secret (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 6IkXASzpdAs · row 6IkXASzpdAs

LAION-DISCO-12M

When God's Chariot Comes

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – When God's Chariot Comes (Bill Remembers Homecoming Heroes) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 7D8MDZD55SM · row 7D8MDZD55SM

LAION-DISCO-12M

When God's Chariot Comes (feat. J.D. Sumner)

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – When God's Chariot Comes (feat. J.D. Sumner) (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 7tTgzGKyu5Y · row 7tTgzGKyu5Y

LAION-DISCO-12M

A Happy Goodman's Story

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Rick Goodman – A Happy Goodman's Story (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video A75Nc5dZAhg · row A75Nc5dZAhg

LAION-DISCO-12M

Will the Circle Be Unbroken

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – Will the Circle Be Unbroken (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video B-kQ3F2tWiY · row B-kQ3F2tWiY

LAION-DISCO-12M

At Calvary (Live)

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman, Lillie Knauls, Faye Speer – At Calvary (Live) (Because He Lives) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video BPaRXFygEzQ · row BPaRXFygEzQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

I've Come Too Far

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – I've Come Too Far (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video BckGa7OdNog · row BckGa7OdNog

LAION-DISCO-12M

Victory Is Ours

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Victory Is Ours (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video CDmPxrRFPUg · row CDmPxrRFPUg

LAION-DISCO-12M

Amazing Grace (Live)

Listed as Howard Goodman, Squire Parsons – Amazing Grace (Live) (Ultimate Gaither Collection) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video EaeDVQM3H3g · row EaeDVQM3H3g

LAION-DISCO-12M

The Blood

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – The Blood (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video EsXiguD2mD4 · row EsXiguD2mD4

LAION-DISCO-12M

Didn't It Rain

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Didn't It Rain (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video GHEBcePXQOo · row GHEBcePXQOo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Clear Title

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – Clear Title (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video I232Fso9_ZI · row I232Fso9_ZI

LAION-DISCO-12M

I'm Living in Canaan Now

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – I'm Living in Canaan Now (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video JSdIhj9r6FI · row JSdIhj9r6FI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Our God Reigns

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Our God Reigns (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video KPlI3Ttfn5Y · row KPlI3Ttfn5Y

LAION-DISCO-12M

Stand & Testify

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, The Martins – Stand & Testify (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Lpl4KwucN9g · row Lpl4KwucN9g

LAION-DISCO-12M

That Sounds Like Home to Me

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – That Sounds Like Home to Me (Set Your Sails) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video LsXeb9nkaC0 · row LsXeb9nkaC0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Hallelujah

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – Hallelujah (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video OdIHDUOASn8 · row OdIHDUOASn8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Softly And Tenderly

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Softly And Tenderly (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video PybQ4EMUmaw · row PybQ4EMUmaw

LAION-DISCO-12M

Child of the King

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Child of the King (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video RyUhxaNzfzA · row RyUhxaNzfzA

LAION-DISCO-12M

When the RolIs are Called Up Yonder

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – When the RolIs are Called Up Yonder (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Ti4p6as5T64 · row Ti4p6as5T64

LAION-DISCO-12M

He Keeps Lifting

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – He Keeps Lifting (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video WlU2MM1JF5A · row WlU2MM1JF5A

LAION-DISCO-12M

Friends

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Janet Paschal – Friends (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video YsLurofCsl0 · row YsLurofCsl0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Let's All Go Down to the River

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, George Younce – Let's All Go Down to the River (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video ZVqtNP_veAI · row ZVqtNP_veAI

LAION-DISCO-12M

It's Beginning to Rain

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – It's Beginning to Rain (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video _Q-ULECRgYI · row _Q-ULECRgYI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Won't It Be Wonderful There

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – Won't It Be Wonderful There (Bill Remembers Homecoming Heroes) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video _xYNTBkXtJM · row _xYNTBkXtJM

LAION-DISCO-12M

The Old Rugged Cross

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – The Old Rugged Cross (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video bTU3K3vV4rQ · row bTU3K3vV4rQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

How Great Thou Art

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – How Great Thou Art (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video cB4ccC42csk · row cB4ccC42csk

LAION-DISCO-12M

I'm Living in Canaan Now

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Gold City – I'm Living in Canaan Now (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video d0lMMygFBLY · row d0lMMygFBLY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Tellin' My Blues Goodbye (Live)

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – Tellin' My Blues Goodbye (Live) (Set Your Sails) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video e72I-XFo4GQ · row e72I-XFo4GQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

I Hold A Clear Title To A Mansion (Live)

Listed as The Happy Goodmans, Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – I Hold A Clear Title To A Mansion (Live) (Always) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video eUbaEQ5paz0 · row eUbaEQ5paz0

LAION-DISCO-12M

I Wouldn't Take Nothing For My Journey (Live)

Listed as Gaither, Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman, Johnny Cook – I Wouldn't Take Nothing For My Journey (Live) (Old Friends (Live)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video h0RtbbFE40Q · row h0RtbbFE40Q

LAION-DISCO-12M

I'd Do It All Over Again

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – I'd Do It All Over Again (Joy for the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video hkSAjNg2tQ8 · row hkSAjNg2tQ8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Peace In The Valley

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Peace In The Valley (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video paZQHCGfc50 · row paZQHCGfc50

LAION-DISCO-12M

Won't It Be Wonderful

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – Won't It Be Wonderful (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video pb3taPBfWyY · row pb3taPBfWyY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Give Up (Live)

Listed as Gaither, Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman, Michael English – Give Up (Live) (Old Friends (Live)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video rVpYZnPALvc · row rVpYZnPALvc

LAION-DISCO-12M

I Wouldn't Take Nothin' for My Journey Now

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – I Wouldn't Take Nothin' for My Journey Now (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video raJTo1e7_nA · row raJTo1e7_nA

LAION-DISCO-12M

What a Lovely Name

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman, Jason Crabb – What a Lovely Name (Southern Homecoming Friends) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video rdZ0dD9Svek · row rdZ0dD9Svek

LAION-DISCO-12M

Love Lifted Me

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Love Lifted Me (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video scxeb22utN4 · row scxeb22utN4

LAION-DISCO-12M

Learning To Lean On Jesus

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Learning To Lean On Jesus (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video usTrLLovf6w · row usTrLLovf6w

LAION-DISCO-12M

I Believe He's Coming Back

Listed as Howard Goodman, Vestal Goodman – I Believe He's Coming Back (Howard & Vestal Goodman Songs from the Journey) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video w98UhUxfbNI · row w98UhUxfbNI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Where We'll Never Grow Old

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Where We'll Never Grow Old (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video xM-Try9lKTc · row xM-Try9lKTc

LAION-DISCO-12M

Tis So Sweet To Trust In Jesus

Listed as Vestal Goodman, Howard Goodman – Tis So Sweet To Trust In Jesus (Vintage Duets) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video xpCwWOcvVAk · row xpCwWOcvVAk

LAION-DISCO-12M

What this means

Last reviewed 2026-09-24.

Presence in a public research dataset shows that a clip of your recording was listed by academic or industry researchers as material for building or testing audio models. It does not by itself show which commercial products, if any, used the clip. The legal picture is moving. On 31 July 2026 the Regional Court of Munich I ruled in GEMA's case against Suno (case 42 O 763/25) that reproducing works for training, holding them in a model in retrievable form, and generating similar outputs can each infringe copyright under German and EU law; the judgment is not final and can be appealed. In the United States, Warner Music Group settled its claims against Suno on 25 November 2025 with a licensing deal, while the parallel claims by Universal and Sony were still pending at that point. Since then BMG (12 August 2026) and Believe/TuneCore (8 September 2026) have signed opt-in licensing deals with Suno.

What you can do

3 routes. None is a guarantee.

UK, PRS members. Send PRS for Music your report and ask what collective or licensing route covers your works.
- PRS for Music and Artificial Intelligence, Version 1 (October 2025), 2025-10-01
- PRS for Music: AI and music copyright, 2026-09-24
Germany, GEMA members. GEMA won a first-instance ruling against Suno on 31 July 2026 and has a licensing model. Ask how they apply to your repertoire.
- GEMA: Suno AI and OpenAI, GEMA sues for fair compensation, 2025-01-21
- DLA Piper: GEMA v Suno, Munich Regional Court judgment of 31 July 2026, 2026-08-28
- Music Business Worldwide: Germany's GEMA launches AI Charter, 2024-11-05
Signed to Warner, BMG or Believe/TuneCore. Each has an opt-in licensing deal with Suno. Ask your label what opting in or out means for you and whether any settlement money reaches artists.
- Music Business Worldwide: Warner Music Group settles with Suno, 2025-11-25
- Music Ally: Suno signs another music licensing deal, with BMG, 2026-08-12
- Music Business Worldwide: Suno inks global deal with Believe, 2026-09-08

Is this you?

Check another name

These pages report where identifiers from public research datasets point. Presence in a dataset is a fact about the dataset, not a claim about the channel or artist, and says nothing about what any company did with the material. If you are this artist and want this page removed, see removals.