Yes. The Dark Tenor has 148 songs listed in a dataset used to train AI music models.

Used for training 148

songs in LAION-DISCO-12M under the artist name

A list of 12 million songs on YouTube Music, gathered by walking artist pages, that LAION published in 2024 for training general music models.

Including Maria durch ein Dornwald ging, Weihnachtszeit (Bonus Studio Track), River Flows on the Edge (Live 2019)

Listed under the artist name 148 songs in LAION-DISCO-12M

Matched exactly: this YouTube Music artist id is the one the dataset lists these songs under.

Maria durch ein Dornwald ging

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Maria durch ein Dornwald ging (Christmas) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video -MG1XP5CI2A · row -MG1XP5CI2A

LAION-DISCO-12M

Weihnachtszeit (Bonus Studio Track)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Weihnachtszeit (Bonus Studio Track) (Weihnachtszeit (Bonus Studio Track)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 0MEXg39mZAw · row 0MEXg39mZAw

LAION-DISCO-12M

River Flows on the Edge (Live 2019)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – River Flows on the Edge (Live 2019) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 0q9gGlpDSTw · row 0q9gGlpDSTw

LAION-DISCO-12M

I Miss You

Listed as The Dark Tenor – I Miss You (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 1633Rgpk5Xw · row 1633Rgpk5Xw

LAION-DISCO-12M

Paradox

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Paradox (Paradox) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 18JTvpRvzBc · row 18JTvpRvzBc

LAION-DISCO-12M

Intro

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Intro (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 1L2fuVmzsFM · row 1L2fuVmzsFM

LAION-DISCO-12M

To Be Somebody (Demo Version)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – To Be Somebody (Demo Version) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 1_E1oyY6jEU · row 1_E1oyY6jEU

LAION-DISCO-12M

Abendlied

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Abendlied (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 4k90Vcw8534 · row 4k90Vcw8534

LAION-DISCO-12M

Volcanoes

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Volcanoes (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 4ogjwaNCKpE · row 4ogjwaNCKpE

LAION-DISCO-12M

Horizon - Somewhere I Belong

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Horizon - Somewhere I Belong (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 6CTkUMymO7k · row 6CTkUMymO7k

LAION-DISCO-12M

Darker Hearts (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Darker Hearts (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 6OzRJBsPu3c · row 6OzRJBsPu3c

LAION-DISCO-12M

Toxic Rain (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Toxic Rain (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video 7SzPuv4pzkc · row 7SzPuv4pzkc

LAION-DISCO-12M

The Four Seasons, Concerto No. 2 in G Minor (Live 2019)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – The Four Seasons, Concerto No. 2 in G Minor (Live 2019) (Alive - 5 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video BBXaFmAeaEc · row BBXaFmAeaEc

LAION-DISCO-12M

Confutatis

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Confutatis (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video DOPBjm--L1Q · row DOPBjm--L1Q

LAION-DISCO-12M

Haunted Hearts (Live 2019)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Haunted Hearts (Live 2019) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video EV-YvP9aP_g · row EV-YvP9aP_g

LAION-DISCO-12M

Unforgettable (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Unforgettable (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video GvRmtF7Tiwo · row GvRmtF7Tiwo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Fade (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Fade (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video H49FBsLt5Cc · row H49FBsLt5Cc

LAION-DISCO-12M

Coming Home (Live 2021)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Coming Home (Live 2021) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video HXq9-4DFTJw · row HXq9-4DFTJw

LAION-DISCO-12M

Save You

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Save You (Symphony Of Light (Second Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Hsq-qA5LDNM · row Hsq-qA5LDNM

LAION-DISCO-12M

To the Unknown (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – To the Unknown (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Iay5CdX6X6Q · row Iay5CdX6X6Q

LAION-DISCO-12M

River of Life (Live 2019)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – River of Life (Live 2019) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video MTFuayoSviY · row MTFuayoSviY

LAION-DISCO-12M

Lascia ch'io Pianga (feat. Angelzoom)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Lascia ch'io Pianga (feat. Angelzoom) (Symphony Of Light) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video PrM3ooLsjpA · row PrM3ooLsjpA

LAION-DISCO-12M

Parla Piu Piano

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Parla Piu Piano (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video RPRW6dtqa3k · row RPRW6dtqa3k

LAION-DISCO-12M

When You Roar / Vivaldi RoXX (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – When You Roar / Vivaldi RoXX (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video SCcM4fdxsT4 · row SCcM4fdxsT4

LAION-DISCO-12M

Hurricane

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Hurricane (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video TS1ZFpbd6IA · row TS1ZFpbd6IA

LAION-DISCO-12M

Dies Irae (Live 2019)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Dies Irae (Live 2019) (Alive - 5 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video VjsB76Pak4I · row VjsB76Pak4I

LAION-DISCO-12M

Colors (Bonus Studio Track)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Colors (Bonus Studio Track) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video Xq89eKxXYm8 · row Xq89eKxXYm8

LAION-DISCO-12M

Out of the Darkness

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Out of the Darkness (Ludwig) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video YsBGnWDtkok · row YsBGnWDtkok

LAION-DISCO-12M

Shatter Me

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Shatter Me (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video aZ12B8CKSw0 · row aZ12B8CKSw0

LAION-DISCO-12M

River Flows On The Edge (Live)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – River Flows On The Edge (Live) (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video avdz2PO23Os · row avdz2PO23Os

LAION-DISCO-12M

River of Life (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – River of Life (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video cKPLVKU8PqQ · row cKPLVKU8PqQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Wild Horses / Dvorak RoXX (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Wild Horses / Dvorak RoXX (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video cVMBmm4mcl0 · row cVMBmm4mcl0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Crystal World

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Crystal World (Symphony Of Light (Second Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video cf-c4zr5-10 · row cf-c4zr5-10

LAION-DISCO-12M

The Brave Never Die

Listed as The Dark Tenor – The Brave Never Die (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video e7t5BNL6ixQ · row e7t5BNL6ixQ

LAION-DISCO-12M

Heidenröslein (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Heidenröslein (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video ekqA4zio3zE · row ekqA4zio3zE

LAION-DISCO-12M

Mountain High

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Mountain High (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video fjiOIAdI7iU · row fjiOIAdI7iU

LAION-DISCO-12M

When You Roar (Live 2021)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – When You Roar (Live 2021) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video ggf-JIFk7B4 · row ggf-JIFk7B4

LAION-DISCO-12M

Ultraviolet Hearts (Live 2021)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Ultraviolet Hearts (Live 2021) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video i_P8I8E5y2s · row i_P8I8E5y2s

LAION-DISCO-12M

Complete (Live 2021)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Complete (Live 2021) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video j5lxTKRYE4g · row j5lxTKRYE4g

LAION-DISCO-12M

Der Mond ist aufgegangen

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Der Mond ist aufgegangen (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video kpwW2uVTRbI · row kpwW2uVTRbI

LAION-DISCO-12M

Paradox (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Paradox (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video mfuyV922A10 · row mfuyV922A10

LAION-DISCO-12M

What If We Love

Listed as The Dark Tenor – What If We Love (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video n7FVWvHVNLc · row n7FVWvHVNLc

LAION-DISCO-12M

Blindfold

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Blindfold (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video osKP4hODRzo · row osKP4hODRzo

LAION-DISCO-12M

Out of the Darkness (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – Out of the Darkness (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video pGIwkuc8W0E · row pGIwkuc8W0E

LAION-DISCO-12M

Unforgettable (Live 2021)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Unforgettable (Live 2021) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video qXpZbVJP0tM · row qXpZbVJP0tM

LAION-DISCO-12M

Renegades

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Renegades (Nightfall Symphony (Deluxe Version)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video r-QLElkUrm0 · row r-QLElkUrm0

LAION-DISCO-12M

Mountain High (Live 2019)

Listed as The Dark Tenor – Mountain High (Live 2019) (Classic RoXX Live) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video s2Bmi5PzAQI · row s2Bmi5PzAQI

LAION-DISCO-12M

You Just Saved Me

Listed as The Dark Tenor – You Just Saved Me (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video swhM1zOl8qg · row swhM1zOl8qg

LAION-DISCO-12M

River Flows on the Edge (Live 2023)

Listed as The Dark Tenor, Billy Andrews – River Flows on the Edge (Live 2023) (Alive 10 Years) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video uSFOcWvlyuE · row uSFOcWvlyuE

LAION-DISCO-12M

A Dance Without The Music

Listed as The Dark Tenor – A Dance Without The Music (Symphony Of Ghosts (Deluxe Edition)) · Watch on YouTube

youtube_video vna7fj3DFd4 · row vna7fj3DFd4

LAION-DISCO-12M

What this means

Last reviewed 2026-09-24.

Presence in a public research dataset shows that a clip of your recording was listed by academic or industry researchers as material for building or testing audio models. It does not by itself show which commercial products, if any, used the clip. The legal picture is moving. On 31 July 2026 the Regional Court of Munich I ruled in GEMA's case against Suno (case 42 O 763/25) that reproducing works for training, holding them in a model in retrievable form, and generating similar outputs can each infringe copyright under German and EU law; the judgment is not final and can be appealed. In the United States, Warner Music Group settled its claims against Suno on 25 November 2025 with a licensing deal, while the parallel claims by Universal and Sony were still pending at that point. Since then BMG (12 August 2026) and Believe/TuneCore (8 September 2026) have signed opt-in licensing deals with Suno.

What you can do

3 routes. None is a guarantee.

UK, PRS members. Send PRS for Music your report and ask what collective or licensing route covers your works.
- PRS for Music and Artificial Intelligence, Version 1 (October 2025), 2025-10-01
- PRS for Music: AI and music copyright, 2026-09-24
Germany, GEMA members. GEMA won a first-instance ruling against Suno on 31 July 2026 and has a licensing model. Ask how they apply to your repertoire.
- GEMA: Suno AI and OpenAI, GEMA sues for fair compensation, 2025-01-21
- DLA Piper: GEMA v Suno, Munich Regional Court judgment of 31 July 2026, 2026-08-28
- Music Business Worldwide: Germany's GEMA launches AI Charter, 2024-11-05
Signed to Warner, BMG or Believe/TuneCore. Each has an opt-in licensing deal with Suno. Ask your label what opting in or out means for you and whether any settlement money reaches artists.
- Music Business Worldwide: Warner Music Group settles with Suno, 2025-11-25
- Music Ally: Suno signs another music licensing deal, with BMG, 2026-08-12
- Music Business Worldwide: Suno inks global deal with Believe, 2026-09-08

Is this you?

Check another name

These pages report where identifiers from public research datasets point. Presence in a dataset is a fact about the dataset, not a claim about the channel or artist, and says nothing about what any company did with the material. If you are this artist and want this page removed, see removals.